Cage Match Gender

To take offense when no offense is intended is, frankly, silly.

Where's the stat's on minority characters/authors?

What you're suggesting is, in essence, Affirmative Action - which is nothing more than good-intentioned reverse-descrimination. That dog won't hunt. It's been proven.

Enjoy the game for what it is - not what it isn't.

To take offense when no offense is intended is indeed silly. Good thing I'm not taking offense! But just because no one wanted to offend does not mean that there isn't a dramatic difference in how women and men are represented in the contest.

Such representation matters. Women and men take their cues about the genre from how the science fiction and fantasy industry presents itself. The Cage Match says that 80% of genre authors should be men, and 80% of the kick-ass characters are men. It may say this implicitly and unintentionally, but it still says it. In doing so the Cage Match paints the genre as a boys club.

Personally, I want 50% of genre authors to be women and 50% of genre readers to be women! I think it makes the whole genre stronger!

As for Affirmative Action, I don't see any need to get drawn into a discussion of real world politics when dealing with fictional characters. There are literally hundreds of fictional characters who it would be fun to imagine fighting one another. Can anyone definitively say that the Wee Free Men are absolutely better than (say) Skade for this contest? Of course not! Since the list of 32 contestants is subjective anyway, why *not* make half of them women?

--Chris

(You bring up a good point about other kinds of minorities, be they racial minorities, sexual-orientation minorities, or anything else you can think of. If you are interested I encourage you to count things up. With a quick look at the field I'd guess you will find some pretty strong disparities in other categories as well.)

"Personally, I want 50% of genre authors to be women and 50% of genre readers to be women! I think it makes the whole genre stronger!"

Personally, I want 100% of genre authors to write fascinating stories based on interesting characters. I couldn't care any less whether those authors and their characters have an "innie" or an "outie".

Exactly how would a 50-50 split make the genre any stonger?

"I don't see any need to get drawn into a discussion of real world politics when dealing with fictional characters."

Me either, so why did you bring real world political-correctness into it with your original post??

While it's a good point, I think it speaks way more (as you said) to the dearth of *good* female characters in fantasy and the lack of female authors. Suvudu I think did a good job of representing females in their match: they could have chose Harry Potter, but instead chose Hermione Granger. And you really can't pull that many good female characters out of older books like Lord of the Rings or especially the Chronicles of Narnia (which are ridiculously sexist at times).

You may have a point with Interview and Arya Stark; however, Arya Stark is a child and they'd already gone lengths to add Hermione. Though that would have made that fight a little fairer, I suppose.

I haven't read most of the other examples you pointed out, but almost all of the characters chosen here are the "main characters" of their book, more or less. Picking just from the great works of fantasy almost guarantees you're going to have a majority of males; showing breadth would require maybe a 64 slot cage match.

Ahem, Xena Warrior Princess plz?

OH, silly me! I meant to add Alia Atreides as well.

I have been reading Scifi and Fantasy since the early 60's. While claiming a "dearth" of female characters then would have been valid. That is just not the case anymore. Both male and female authors have some marvelous female "kick-a$$" characters.
Lady Juniper MacKensie; S. M. Sirling author.
Elena Michaels; Kelly Armstrong author,
Eve Dallas; J.D. Robb author
And those are just the ones I can think of with 10 or more books in the series. I don't care if it is PC or not, there should have been more women in the match-up.

I will say that one thing we've regretted was pitting two female characters against each other in the first round (Anita Blake and Polgara). To be fair, we were just as regretful of having two SF characters against each other in the first round (The Shrike and Arthur Dent). In both cases, we eliminated at least one person from a more under-represented aspect of the broader SF/F genre.

That said, I will say we didn't actively snub any women characters. We just tried to include the biggest characters, period (with some caveats, which are secret...). And we didn't actively snub women authors. We just sat around, thought: "Who's cool", and went with it.

Still, I like that you're bringing this up, because it is an issue that should be discussed--if not for this cage match specifically, than for the genre in general.

So this leads me to the question: do men relate to female fantasy/scifi heroes? Do they enjoy reading about those as much as they do as reading about male heroes?

I know some men that just aren't interested in reading books in which the main character is a woman. While women don't seem to mind so much about the gender of the hero. Maybe because women don't have as much of a choice, even female authors often have male heroes. The female secondary character certainly has grown in popularity since the early days of the genre, but if we're talking 'biggest character' there still is a lag. Do male heroes sell better?

@ illuminatedwax: I wouldn't call the Chronicles of Narnia "ridiculously sexist". Many of them were, in fact, sexist in comparison to our modern views of the issue. But for the time they were quite ordinary. Look, however, at The Horse and His Boy, which was ahead of its time in terms of gender equality.

@ Lenalena: Most female characters I have read are poorly written. The reason seems to be that most authors cannot write outside of their own experiences very well ("write what you know", after all). Since we've established that Sci-Fi\Fantasy authors have tended to be men in the past, it is no surprise that most female characters are so written. For my part, I'd rather a male author write good male characters, and a female author write good female characters, than for either gender to step outside of their areas of personal experience and write something unconvincing. Personally, I'm more offended by a generalized and stilted portrayal of a female character than by the omission of one.

If the publishing world is still somehow holding onto gender prejudice after the widespread success of Harry Potter and Twilight, then I'd say the gender bias belongs to the business, and not to the folks at Suvudu for compiling a list of their favorite characters.

To be fair, I haven't heard a single male question the necessity of a female protagonist in Twilight, but have heard females question the gender of many a male protagonist. That, at least, indicates to me that men aren't the only ones who may have a problem reading a story based on the protagonist's gender.

I think the selection is a pretty fair representation of the women in the genre at large! No point shoving in women who would not be able to play in this field (as it is I think Lyra was a trifle forced - would rather have seen, say, Lanfear from WOT (now _there's_ a powerful woman in her own right!) or perhaps Arkady/Bayta Darrell from the Foundation series, or Teela Brown (turned protector, maybe?), if we needed a woman! Or, add another GRRM character and put in Dany+dragons....all of these would hold their own better than Lyra - yes, even Arkady. Intelligence trumps alethiometer anytime)

I had rather hoped to see Granny Weatherwax too - but hold on, aren't the Nac Mac Feagles kinda matriarchal? ;) Does that count, I wonder....maybe we could award them a 0.3 or something?

Oh, and with regards to the statement "Women and men take their cues about the genre from how the science fiction and fantasy industry presents itself. The Cage Match says that 80% of genre authors should be men, and 80% of the kick-ass characters are men."....maybe I'm reading you wrong, but aren't you kind of confusing cause and effect here? Only Cthulhu (and, possibly, Chuck Norris) are allowed to do that y'know...

I also noticed the lack of women. I was shocked that Alanna was not in this! She has defeated gods, and is a warrior mage.

Other women who I think could have gone all the way are: Rhapsody (although we do have a lot of naming mages already); Jaenelle (black jewels books); Phedre (Kusheil books) -- she isn't much of a fighter, but she can take a lot of punishment and knows the name of God (which in her world is like naming anything)!; or even the Crow girls (from the de Lint books).

My problem was not actually the number of women, but the lack of strong women (as lakesidy said). I just can't see Lyra or Hermione going far in these battles, at all. Anita Blake was a nice shout-out, but no way could she go far. And Kahlan has to get way too close (although her knife throwing is sweet in the show) to be a serious contender.

Maybe my secondary list has some less-popular women in it and it is good for most voters to know the characters, but people have to know Alanna.

Also, perhaps I misread Foreshadowing, but although the main character in Twilight is a woman, I would *never* consider her a heroine. More a damsel. It makes me so sad that I know so many non-fantasy readers who have only read those books.

i hate to state something that is proven over and over in history...but here goes

with a few exceptions i.e. giving birth, being emo, etc

Man > Woman
Male Ninja > Female Ninja
Male chef > Female chef
Male Doctor > Female Doctor
Male (insert title) > Female (insert title)

it's science.

My math has 5 females not 4 in the opening 32 Khalan, Polgra, Anita, Lyra, Hermione. One sexless robot and one sexless demonic Elder God. 1 dragon I dont know what sex. and 24 males. Seems about representitive of the heroes in the genres as a whole.

Notable Misses Missed: Rhapsody as many have said, Honor Harrington, And Paksenarion. These are just from my library and limited to Main Characters. But if one takes the Main characters and villians and or signifigant supporting Characters from the genre You would realy be stretching it to try a half and half feild sex wise... Political correctness and pandering to all the possibly slighted groups leads to a bad contest here I think.

Stick with the best/ most compelling characters in a combat situation. Thanks for the event svudu.

Quotas are not applicable in the Fantasy genre: there are fictional all-men/all-women worlds, there are worlds where changing the sex is on par with changing your clothes (Glasshouse, Charles Stross), there are worlds where 'man' and 'woman' are defined differently (are there in fact any fictonal worlds where the definition could be said to be the same? - is a she-elf a woman?)

To introduce real-world quotas on fiction is ridiculous (and to prove it, i'm going for reductio ad absurdum, so sorry): Should there be x% Christians? x% Not-rosy-white? x% Psychologically-norm? x% gays? x% Poor?
Most of the entrants are not even human (whatever that may mean in a Fantasy context) - Aragorn? not human. Ged? What was the last human you saw pulling down lightning?

I can understand the plight of the thread-starter, and empathise with it; realise, though, that even in the real world the concept of male and female is an abstract one: People mostly subscribe to one or the other, or are subscribed by their environment, yet however you physically define it (be it testosterone levels, organs or genetics)- there will always be 'manly' women, and 'womanly' men, proving that the distinction is not anything factual.

As to the "[..] and 80% of the kick-ass characters are men" -> i too think that 80% (or more) of kick-ass characters are men. The real question re: what-is-sad-about-this seems to me to be: Why 'kick-ass'? Is Conan a role model? should Conan, rewrittten as the female Conine be a role model for women?

And about the "I want 50% of genre authors to be women [..]" - That is wishing for an effect, instead of a cause. Just as in any other literary category, the reading preferences of the buyers determine the successful authors. I can not for the life of me explain why someone like Dan Brown could rise to where he is, but to wish for 'more good authors' is actually wishing for 'less lobotomized readers'.

Suzie Shooter from the "Nightside" series could go pretty far. Also, Surreal from the "Black Jewels" series, and Brienne of Tarth from the later "Song of Ice and Fire" books.

Have you read these books?

Star Wars, Lord of the Rings, Harry Potter and Ever Quest.

What about these movies. X-Men and The Matrix

If you have you’ll love reading the novels at the website below.

www.eivelasquez.com

I see no reason for disappointment if women are barely represented in the contest. We must not speak about a battle of the sexes… It doesn't really matter who wrote the book, if it is interesting and really worth attention, it is gonna win. Besides there are many successful science fiction and fantasy authors among women!Just think of Twilight or Harry Potter)))

Thank you for another essential article. Where else could anyone get that kind of information in such a complete way of writing? I have a presentation incoming week, and I am on the lookout for such information.j
hermes birkin

The participation of female in the cage matches are really expected by the keen viewers of the matches all over the world. It is really good that you have actually provided us with the statistics and data in pure numbers about the participation of male and female fictional characters of the cage matches. I think I wouldn't able to find any such analysis anywhere in the Internet other than here. I find this post really informative and interesting as well. We are looking forward to more like this soon.

Election is a huge tournament. Americans can have the brand new leader. They also contain in election.
http://www.memoryfoammattress2u.com/

Abantailak zure enpresa edo gutxienekoa izan daiteke joera dirua galtzeko. Hau gertatuko jarraitzen baduzu, zure negozio huts egingo du aurrera edota joera gelditu.
Business sales

Prezioak balio edo kalitate oinarritzen da. Prezioei buruzko estrategia produktu edo zerbitzuaren kalitatea oinarritzen da oso ona denean negozio duten bezero eta irtenbideak sare bat pertsona aberatsen geruza batean edo gutxienez nahikoa diru kalitatezko produktu edo zerbitzu erosi behar du.
Business sales

Trošak je iznos novca potreban da bi i prodavati proizvode i vrijednost je iznos novca plaćen od strane potrošača dobiti proizvod koji je određen potrebama kupaca i kupaca percepcije o prednosti vašeg proizvoda.
Electronic Medical Records Software

Ako koristite ovu strategiju, uvijek biste trebali obratiti pozornost na to tko vašim konkurentima i kako se postaviti cijene strategije u svoje poslovanje. Dakle, cijena se određuje ovu strategiju tendira da bude vrlo nepostojan.
Electronic Medical Records Software

Ar principu par prioritāti klientu, kur to var viegli nolasīt ar esošajiem un potenciālajiem klientiem, jūs varat sagaidīt jūsu klientiem un izredzes nebūs pārsteigts pa solim uzlabojot cenu, jums darīt jūsu uzņēmējdarbības jomā.
secure delete

Ar principu par prioritāti klientu, kur to var viegli nolasīt ar esošajiem un potenciālajiem klientiem, jūs varat sagaidīt jūsu klientiem un izredzes nebūs pārsteigts pa solim uzlabojot cenu, jums darīt jūsu uzņēmējdarbības jomā.
secure delete

Ar principu par prioritāti klientu, kur to var viegli nolasīt ar esošajiem un potenciālajiem klientiem, jūs varat sagaidīt jūsu klientiem un izredzes nebūs pārsteigts pa solim uzlabojot cenu, jums darīt jūsu uzņēmējdarbības jomā.
secure delete

Papildus iespējai palielināt peļņas summas, kas jūsu biznesu, tas solis var būt arī stratēģisks gājiens, lai konkurētu ar jūsu konkurentiem. Konkurence cenu līmeni vienmēr nosaka, pamatojoties uz vērtību un īpašas kvalitātes produktu vai pakalpojumu jūs pārdodat.
secure delete

Gender becomes people's concern in social life. It is because it discusses about women and man position. The position of men is usually higher than women. car covers

Some people subject in gender issue. Lots of the gender activists are ladies. They changed into a feminist. wall decal

Gender becomes people's obstacle in social lifestyles. Reason why it discusses about women folk and man position. The position of men will likely be increased than women.
handy orten

Gender is very sensitive issue among women. It is because most of the topic of the gender discuss about women. Then, it is sometimes related to feminism issue even thought it is quite different. free grants for college

Plan hoeveel kapitaal u nodig heeft. Het aantal venture capital is sterk afhankelijk van het soort bedrijf zou je Bika. Als uw bedrijf is actief in de productie en verkoop, ben je geneigd kaan contant groter dan wanneer uw bedrijf is in de dienstverlening.
online payday loans

Gender may be very sensitive obstacle among women. It is because lots of the subject matter of the gender talk about about women. Then, it really is oftentimes concerning feminism obstacle even notion it really is exceptionally different. Boys Suits

Gender is awfully delicate drawback among girls. For the reason that many of the topic of the gender discuss about girls. Then, it truly is repeatedly regarding feminism drawback even inspiration it truly is distinctly different. web design london

Some people concern in gender issue. Most of the gender activists are women. They become a feminist. sell ebooks

Gender is usually a hot topic. It is because many people are interesting in talking about gender. It sometimes becomes a topic that talk widely. sell ebooks

Gender issue is one kind of topic that usually discuss in Letter faculty. The gender issue is not just discuss. The students and the lecturers discuss about gender because many stories from novel, plays, and poetry have gender issue in the story. Medical billing

Digital report turns into the essential that utilized in place of business. This is because today americans use pc. They do some thing in pc to make them work easily. Bosch Multi-x blades

Gender trouble is one kind of theme that sometimes focus on in Letter school. The gender trouble is not only focus on. The students and the lecturers focus on about gender due to the fact that many experiences from novel, performs, and poetry have gender trouble in the story. bigger penis

Some human beings concern in gender situation. Lots of the gender activists are women folk. They become a feminist. Christmas gift ideas

Gender issue is one form of theme that usually focus on in Letter school. The gender issue isn't just focus on. The scholars and the lecturers focus on about gender considering that many experiences from novel, performs, and poetry have gender issue inside the story. Dresses for Girls

Gender will become people's drawback in social life. It's because it discusses about women and man situation. The situation of guys is typically increased than women. Tax accountants Sydney

Sometimes, gender becomes an issue that feature in a novel or other fiction works. It is because the gender issue is like a daily life. It usually happens everyday. ZeekRewards

Media works through human mind. Media knows the flow of human behavior, so they could determine the way they should influence people.
granny pussy

Media works through human mind. Media knows the flow of human behavior, so they could determine the way they should influence people.
granny pussy

Quite many creator still problem about gender with or devoid of recognize. That is true trouble that on the whole show up. It occurred in lifestyle devoid of individuals recognize it. AFL Tips

The sky view is mostly a terrific object for the snapshot. The colour of the sky is smooth so it will be exact for every object. It may be used because the major heritage for the photo. ab testing

Many writer still concern about gender with or without realize. It is real situation that commonly happen. It happened in daily life without people realize it. new york advertising

Gender predicament still exists within the novel or fiction books. There's given that gender considerations are still discuss in authentic lifestyles. So it make the interesting one for the reader. free ads

Gender predicament still exists within the novel or fiction books. There's given that gender considerations are still discuss in authentic lifestyles. So it make the interesting one for the reader. free ads

Many author nevertheless concern about gender with or with out know. It is genuine position that in the main manifest. It took place in way of life with out we know it. Buy Latisse

Press might actually help guys in publishing. It may create specific picture in keeping with the click perspective. It could actually contain politic which have an effect on the publishing. Styrofoam Ceiling Tiles

TA trip to Rajasthan Tory Burch Shoes earlier this year inspired Tory Burch's latest collection. What did the globe-trotting designer take away from the Tory Burch WedgesIndian state? Vibrant colors, of course.

Many people who concern about gender mostly are female. It is because they knows about feminism which very popular. There are only few male that concern about the gender issue.
breast pump review

Gender is likely one of the issues that usually utilized in the literary ebook. The gender ebook is made to peer the unseen tournament of existence. The gender is generally about girls which not often used. electric trolley

Gender quandary still exists in the novel or fiction books. There's for the reason that gender problems are still focus on in authentic existence. So it make the attention-grabbing one for the reader. Cocktail Dresses

Many individuals who difficulty about gender in general are woman. The reason is, they is aware of about feminism which very talked-about. There are in simple terms few male that difficulty about the gender issue. get followers

Gender is one of the topics that usually used in the literary book. The gender book is made to see the unseen event of life. The gender is mostly about women which rarely used. Soundclick instrumentals

Gender is one of the subjects that usually used in the literary e-book. The gender e-book is made to peer the unseen match of life. The gender is generally about females which not often used. gambling sites online

Gender is one of the subjects that usually used in the literary e-book. The gender e-book is made to peer the unseen match of life. The gender is generally about females which not often used. gambling sites online

I like cheap clothes very much,they are in high quality and inexpensive, so I think everyone will be interested in it,is it right?

Do you like motorcycling and have your own motor equiments?You can come here Belstaff Outlet to find.

Gender is probably the themes that sometimes used in the literary book. The gender book is made to see the unseen match of lifestyles. The gender is generally about women which rarely used. visual impact for women

A lot of those that issue about gender as a rule are girl. The reason for this is that they is familiar with about feminism which very hot. There are in basic terms few male that issue about the gender issue. payday advance loans

In certain job, the gender is a problem. Sometimes, a job is not for woman. Therefore, woman cannot have what the man get. herbalife shakes

Gender issue is a common thing in every thing. It is because the gender can be seen from any perspective. People can discuss gender issue in any field. cheap logo design

Raheja Builder Gurgaon launched luxury residential Project Raheja revanta Sector 78 in unique design with peaceful city life atmosphere.
raheja latest project | raheja upcoming project

Gender trouble is a standard thing in every part. The reason for this is that the gender may well be visible from any viewpoint. people can discuss gender trouble in any field. best android tablet

Gender concern is a common factor in every part. The reason for this is that the gender will also be noticeable from any viewpoint. individuals can focus on gender concern in any field. NRL News

Gender concern is a common factor in every part. The reason for this is that the gender will also be noticeable from any viewpoint. individuals can focus on gender concern in any field. NRL News